Illegal Xboxes 'worth £500,000' seized in Birmingham

Status
Not open for further replies.

secgc

BANNED
The way that Trading Standards, FACT & ELSPA look @ the value of things i.e COPIED games, is an overall "amount" that may have been made, & what it has cost the industry, NOT what the stuff they have siezed is actually worth !
If this person, who was busted, has dvd duplicators *copyboxes*, several thousand blank dual layer discs etc*, they take a look into, what the costs to the industry would be, so for instance, if they found 200 copies of DUKE NUKEM, they take it into account of 200 x £40, whicj is £8000, not the value of the blank discs, which is about £26 if using cheap media !!
This person or persons, have obviously making profit, from this venture, & have been "watched" for a while, and have probably have had "test purchases" made by TS, as for the 450 copied games, that's not alot really, but having 250 modified consoles, that is - it proves to FACT & TS, that they are quite regularly selling modified to circumnavigate electronic devices.
This can carry a 10 year sentence, for SERIOUS MIS-USE OF COMPUTER EQUIPMENT
 

crazycastle

Senior Member
Nov 29, 2009
137
18
uk
cmon who was it.........hands up..........oh you can't, they're firmly fixed behind your back, lol.

Seriously though, you get more time for this kind of stuff than REAL crimes, like the two that were sentenced today in the UK for a masive bust on Child p*rn images and only got 33 months each.

Our rules,regulations and sentences in the UK are in dire need of a rethink!!
 

Morpheuspt

VIP Member
Apr 20, 2011
317
0
Portugal
what is illegal about a usb to sata convertor or a pin with 3 wires and a switch ?

what is illegal about replacing your dvd drive with another if your drive is faulty and programming the new drive with your dvd key ?

nothing illegal at all.

However people who advertise flashing - thats illegal and ppl selling copied games - thats illegal. You have to laugh when you see all these guys saying "backups is legal" - they are clueless and have absolutley no idea what they are talking about.
You're absolutely right. However this bit
what is illegal about replacing your dvd drive with another if your drive is faulty and programming the new drive with your dvd key ?
Is only valid if you replace stock with stock. Flashing with something other than stock, in EU, is illegal. In the US it isn't.
 
Last edited:

rick48235

VIP Member
Sep 14, 2010
613
33
MICH
I flash for free that is not a crime as long as they dont see any money pass. They buy thier own store brought games and copy them to pertect from straches if i had 100 xboxes
 

cloppo

Senior Member
Jan 19, 2011
145
16
Reading, UK
Yep Big time sh*t
 

Marlec

Full Member
Apr 11, 2010
96
0
Netherlands
You have to laugh at their numbers of 500,000 lol

250 consoles @ 200 each = 50,000
450 games @ 60 each = 27,000

Thats 77,000 MAX !

Stupid.
60 quid for an illegal copy Uber ?? thats kinda of defeating the pirate`s object isnt it ?? i think you prob mean 6 quid right ??

i might stop flashing my bits in public but thats about it. ;)
Ah right so that was you outside by the Mc Donalds in Stoke. :D
 

Flashy

VIP Member
Jan 9, 2011
241
0
Mostly at home
Console flashing is illegal in the EU.
You're making it a bit easy for yourself there. The European Union Copyright Directive (EUCD = InfoSoc) is a vague directive that opens up alot of exclusion possibilities for the individual EU-country. The full text is available via EurLex and well worth a read. But be aware that you will also need knowledge of your local laws to fully grasp the situation in your country. As I know only the very basics of Portuguese legal system, I can't help you there, I'm afraid.

what is illegal about a usb to sata convertor or a pin with 3 wires and a switch ?
Possibly alot, I'm afraid. If you consider flashing CFW generelly illegal, then the X360 USB Pro would probably fall under Art. 6 II c) EUCD.

But even if it doesn't, it's missing vital tests and signatures that prevents legal commercial trading of it in the EU. Basically each of your EU resellers could be fined for selling them, which would most likely end in immediate bankruptcy of said reseller. But I already reported that to staff a few weeks back.
 

Morpheuspt

VIP Member
Apr 20, 2011
317
0
Portugal
You're making it a bit easy for yourself there. The European Union Copyright Directive (EUCD = InfoSoc) is a vague directive that opens up alot of exclusion possibilities for the individual EU-country. The full text is available via EurLex and well worth a read. But be aware that you will also need knowledge of your local laws to fully grasp the situation in your country. As I know only the very basics of Portuguese legal system, I can't help you there, I'm afraid.
Sure it's vague, as most laws are. However, it's clearly distinctive that any infringement of anti-circumvention measures put in place to avoid copyright theft is illegal. And that's what we do.

The InfoSoc Directive has been applied everywhere, with the exception of some regions of Spain, due to autonomous issues.
 

Flashy

VIP Member
Jan 9, 2011
241
0
Mostly at home
Sure it's vague, as most laws are.
Well, a EU-directive is not technically a "law". A regulation on the other hand, would be.
Laws aren't generally vague, they are abstract. That's a big difference. A good law is abstract while having enough content to make sure every situation X can be answered with a definitive outcome Y.

However, it's clearly distinctive that any infringement of anti-circumvention measures put in place to avoid copyright theft is illegal. And that's what we do.
I highly disagree there. If at all, it clearly states that not every circumvention of such measures is illegal.

Mind you, I'm not saying it's legal. I'm just saying you need to actually perform an in-depth analysis of the per-country situation to come to any conclusion.


Edit: With "vague" I meant the technical side of the EUCD. The possibilities of exclusions are a completely different point that touches the national application of the directive. Sorry if that wasn't clear from my first post. As I said, the full text is available for free and well worth reading.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.