NTFS view offline possible, why not FATX (defrag)? as either homebrew or pc app?

XeniumRefugee

Full Member
Aug 18, 2005
28
0
gamersha794 said:
[defragging is not] worth the time and effort because

1.) unless you move many things around on your HD on a regular basis(think file-sharing), you don't need one.
I regulary copy episodes and movies to G:, then later delete batches. I partition my primary PC drive for the same reason: to curtail fragmentation. Files on C: rarely change. "Documents and Settings" live on D:, while torrents and other downloads are written to E:. The pagefile lives on G: which is a different physical drive. Internet cache lives on a much smaller FAT partition on the second drive. All other partitions are NTFS.

This limits fragmentation to a particular physical boundry on the media -- effectively "reducing" fragmentation.

There are a variety of defragmentation tools that can be run from a miniPE environment. I usually defrag the PC "offline".

Now, there are also tools that will allow one to access NTFS partitions "offline" as well as linux partitions irrespective of permissions. I see no reason why a competant programmer (I'm not a programmer) couldn't design a filesystem abstration layer or utility to read FATX offline: either from an XBOX homebrew application, or connected to a PC.

That it hasn't happened yet does not necessarily mean that no one has tried it. If it hasn't been tried then ... well try hoping or find yourself an engineer or extremely geeky programmer. Gee, where ever could we find extremely geeky programmers...

$0.03
 
Last edited:

XeniumRefugee

Full Member
Aug 18, 2005
28
0
[font=verdana, arial, helvetica]abstration layer = [/font][font=verdana, arial, helvetica]abstraction layer[/font]
 

digthebox

VIP Member
Dec 2, 2004
595
0
UK
my you have been a busy little poster - shame you have started the same topic(FATX defrag) in more than one thread. WHY?

simple answer really is - there really aint a great need to defrag an xbox hard drive.

people have explained the reasons in your other thread in the X3 Requests area
 

XeniumRefugee

Full Member
Aug 18, 2005
28
0
the board wouldn't let me delete the other post. Since I brought a new idea to the table, and didn't want to recycle opinion I started a new post. :)